HRVATO / BLOG / CROATIAN CULTURE & HERITAGE

Croatian Community in Cleveland: History, Churches & Croatian-American Life

Explore Cleveland's Croatian community, from the first immigrants on St. Clair Avenue and St. Paul Croatian Church to the American Croatian Lodge in Eastlake and the Croatian Cultural Garden.

HRVATO Editorial Team 9 min read
Croatian Culture & Heritage Downtown Cleveland, Ohio skyline on Lake Erie, home to one of America's oldest Croatian communities

The story

HRVATO JOURNAL
Croatian Culture & Heritage 9 MIN READ

Cleveland has one of the oldest Croatian communities in the United States. Croatians first arrived in the late 1860s, built their first parish in 1902, and still gather today at a Croatian church on East 40th Street, a large Croatian lodge on the lakeshore in Eastlake and a Croatian garden in Rockefeller Park.

This guide covers how the community formed, where Croatians lived and worked, the churches and halls they built, and where to find Croatian Cleveland now. It's part of our wider guide to Croatian Americans, which covers every major Croatian community in the country. ⏱️ 8-min read

How Many Croatians Live in Cleveland?

There is no exact count, because U.S. ancestry figures depend on how people describe themselves. The best historical numbers come from the Encyclopedia of Cleveland History at Case Western Reserve University:

  • About 12,000 Croatians lived in Cleveland by the 1920s, and the 1940 census counted 12,540.
  • Around 8,000 more arrived in Greater Cleveland between 1967 and 1971 alone.
  • By 1985, more than 25,000 people of full or partial Croatian descent lived in the area.
  • In 1990, Greater Cleveland had over 15,000 people whose main ancestry was Croatian, the fourth-largest Croatian population in the U.S. after Pittsburgh, Chicago and New York.

Today the community is spread across Cuyahoga and Lake counties, from the old East Side neighborhoods out to Euclid, Eastlake, Willoughby and Mentor. To see how Cleveland compares with other cities, read where Croatian Americans live.

When Did Croatians Come to Cleveland?

The first Croatians reached Cleveland in the late 1860s, mostly moving in from neighboring states for work in industry and construction. Large numbers followed from about 1890, and the movement peaked around 1910.

Black and white photo of immigrant men lined up for medical inspection at Ellis Island
Medical inspection at Ellis Island, where many Croatian immigrants first entered the United States. Photo: The New York Public Library / Unsplash

Cleveland's Croatians arrived in three main waves:

  • 1860s to 1918. Mostly young men from rural families in southern and northwestern Croatia, many planning to earn money and go home.
  • 1919 to 1941. Families joined the men who stayed, and newcomers arrived from every Croatian region, including Slavonia, Dalmatia, Istria and Bosnia and Herzegovina.
  • 1945 to the 1980s. Refugees and political exiles who left communist Yugoslavia, followed by a large wave of workers and families in the late 1960s.

The story of these waves across the whole country is told in our history of Croatian immigration to America.

St. Clair and East 40th: Cleveland's First Croatian Neighborhood

Many early Croatians settled beside the Slovenians, who had been their neighbors back home and were already established along St. Clair Avenue. The corner of East 40th Street and St. Clair became the heart of Croatian Cleveland.

The first arrivals were mostly single men living in boarding houses. They worked for American Steel & Wire, Otis Steel, the Van Dorn Iron Works, Cleveland Twist Drill and the railroads. Most were unskilled laborers, doing hard, often dangerous work for long hours.

By 1910 Croatian families had spread into Collinwood, Glenville, Nottingham, Euclid and West Park. Collinwood in particular grew into a second Croatian center, with its own lodges and later its own Croatian Home on Waterloo Road.

Croatian Churches in Cleveland

St. Paul Croatian Church

The early Croatians first worshipped at St. Vitus, the Slovenian parish, but wanted a priest who spoke their language. In July 1901 they bought land on East 40th Street, just south of St. Clair. Fr. Milan Sutlić arrived from Croatia and founded St. Paul Croatian Church in November 1902 (parish history).

The cornerstone was laid on August 2, 1903, and the first Mass in the new church was held on Easter Sunday 1904. His successor, Fr. Niko Gršković, opened a parish school in 1910 and became one of the best-known Croatian activists and newspaper editors in America.

After World War II, St. Paul's helped many Croatian refugees find homes and jobs in Cleveland. It is still the city's Croatian Catholic parish and a center of community life, at 1369 East 40th Street. Check the parish directly for current Mass times in Croatian and English.

St. Nicholas Croatian Byzantine Catholic Church

Cleveland's very first Croatian parish was actually St. Nicholas, a Byzantine Rite Catholic church founded by Fr. Mile Golubić and about 50 families from the Žumberak area. It started near East 41st and St. Clair and moved in 1913 to East 36th and Superior, where the parish dedicated a new church in 1975. St. Nicholas closed in 2020 as attendance fell, but its history is part of the story of many Cleveland families with roots in Žumberak.

Lodges, Halls and Croatian Organizations

Like Croatians in every American city, Cleveland's immigrants built mutual-aid societies to pay for funerals and help the sick and injured. The first Cleveland lodges of the National Croatian Society opened in 1895 and 1897. Lodge 235, founded in Collinwood in 1906 and named "Croatian Liberty," became an important social and patriotic center.

Cleveland hosted national conventions of the National Croatian Society in 1896 and 1915. In 1926 the first convention of the newly formed Croatian Fraternal Union met in the city, and from 1933 the community held large annual Croatian Days that drew thousands of people.

The post-war decades added the "Lisinski" Singing Society, an American-Croatian Academic Club, folklore groups and soccer clubs. In 1972 the community bought the Croatian Center, more than 100 acres on Mulberry Road in Chesterland.

The American Croatian Lodge in Eastlake

On September 29, 1984, Croatians dedicated the Croatian National Home on Lakeshore Boulevard in Eastlake. It cost more than $2.5 million and became the centerpiece of the community. Today the American Croatian Lodge at 34900 Lakeshore Boulevard hosts weddings, banquets, Easter and Christmas events and Croatian concerts, and it's the easiest place for a newcomer to plug into Croatian Cleveland.

The Croatian Heritage Museum & Library

Inside the same building in Eastlake is the Croatian Heritage Museum & Library, run by volunteers of the nonprofit Our Croatia, Inc. Planning began in 1983, and the first exhibit opened in the lodge's ballroom in August 1984. The library got its permanent home next to the museum in 2005 and is a lending library, so you can borrow Croatian history and fiction.

The museum puts on rotating exhibits on folk art, weaving, wedding traditions and Croatian artists, plus a "Croatians Celebrate Christmas" open house most Decembers. Admission is free. Check the museum's website for current opening hours before you go.

The Croatian Cultural Garden

Cleveland's Cultural Gardens in Rockefeller Park honor dozens of the city's ethnic communities. The Croatian Cultural Garden, at 1141 Martin Luther King Jr. Drive, was dedicated in June 2012.

It's full of Croatian details worth knowing before you visit:

  • A waterfall between the two levels recalls Plitvice Lakes and Krka.
  • The lower walkway is shaped like a licitar heart, the decorated honey-dough hearts sold at Croatian fairs.
  • In the center stands the Immigrant Mother statue by Joseph Turkaly, a Croatian-born Cleveland sculptor, with Glagolitic letters and the Croatian coat of arms (grb) on its base.
  • The upper plaza has a replica of the baptismal font of Prince Višeslav, a symbol of Croatia's conversion to Christianity, and six benches made of stone from the island of Brač.

The Cultural Gardens also hold One World Day each summer, a festival of music, food and costume from the communities behind the gardens.

Tamburica, Kolo and Croatian Culture in Cleveland

Music has always held Croatian Cleveland together. Tamburica orchestras played at lodge dances for over a century, and youth groups such as the Cleveland Junior Tamburitzans still teach children to play and to dance the kolo. Visiting folklore groups from Croatia regularly perform at the American Croatian Lodge.

Women in traditional Croatian folk costume in the village of Buševec, Croatia
Traditional folk dress in Buševec, Croatia. Village costumes like these inspire the outfits of Croatian-American kolo groups. Photo: Kat von Wood / Unsplash

Food does the same job at home. In many Cleveland Croatian families, Christmas still means sarma, walnut and poppy seed rolls and fritule, even where the Croatian language has faded. The dishes often reveal where in Croatia a family came from. Our guide to Croatian food and culture explains the regional differences.

Where to Find Croatian Cleveland Today

  • St. Paul Croatian Church, 1369 East 40th Street, Cleveland: the community's Catholic parish.
  • American Croatian Lodge, 34900 Lakeshore Boulevard, Eastlake: events, banquets and Croatian holidays.
  • Croatian Heritage Museum & Library, at the lodge in Eastlake: exhibits and a lending library.
  • Croatian Cultural Garden, 1141 Martin Luther King Jr. Drive, Rockefeller Park.
  • Croatian Center, Mulberry Road, Chesterland: the community's grounds east of the city.

Events and hours change, so check each organization's website or social media before visiting.

Tracing Croatian Roots in Cleveland

If your family came through Cleveland, a few records are especially useful:

  • Parish records at St. Paul's and St. Nicholas often name the village a person was born in, which U.S. documents usually don't.
  • Lodge membership and insurance records from the National Croatian Society and Croatian Fraternal Union list members, beneficiaries and sometimes hometowns.
  • Naturalization papers and ship manifests give arrival dates and the last place of residence in Europe.
  • The family surname itself, once you find its original spelling, can point to a region of Croatia. Our guide to Croatian surnames explains how.

A DNA test can add another piece of the puzzle. Read what Croatian DNA results can and can't tell you before you buy one.

Frequently Asked Questions About Croatians in Cleveland

Is there a Croatian church in Cleveland?

Yes. St. Paul Croatian Church at 1369 East 40th Street has served Croatian Catholics since 1902. St. Nicholas, the Croatian Byzantine Catholic parish at East 36th and Superior, closed in 2020.

Where do Croatians gather in Cleveland?

The main gathering place is the American Croatian Lodge in Eastlake, which also houses the Croatian Heritage Museum & Library. St. Paul's parish, the Croatian Center in Chesterland and the Croatian Cultural Garden in Rockefeller Park host events too.

When did Croatians come to Cleveland?

The first Croatians arrived in the late 1860s. Immigration grew from about 1890, peaked around 1910, and saw another large wave after World War II and in the late 1960s.

Where did Cleveland's Croatians first live?

Mostly along St. Clair Avenue on the East Side, around East 40th Street, next to the Slovenian community. Later they spread to Collinwood, Euclid and the eastern suburbs.

Is there a Croatian garden in Cleveland?

Yes. The Croatian Cultural Garden at 1141 Martin Luther King Jr. Drive opened in 2012 and features the Immigrant Mother statue, a waterfall and benches of Brač stone.

Celebrate Your Croatian Heritage

Bring your family's story home with a Croatian city map print of Zagreb, Split, Dubrovnik or one of 25 more Croatian cities, the dish you grew up with from the Croatian Food Alphabet, framed and ready to hang or as a matte poster, or Croatian clothing for men, women and kids.

Keep reading: The Croatian community in Chicago · The Croatian community in Detroit · Where Croatian Americans live · The Croatian diaspora

Sources

Thanks for reading the HRVATO Journal. ← Back to all articles

Discover more of HRVATO.

Explore Croatian culture, travel and traditions, and connect with Croatians around the world.

Explore community